When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
ROBERT PORTNER
BREWING CO.
TRADE TIVOLI MARK
ALEXANDRIA, VA.
THIS BOTTLE
NOT TO BE SOLD
The centerpiece is Portner’s distinctive double-diamond TIVOLI trademark. “Tivoli” was cleverly promoted as a reversal or approximation of “I Lov It,” making it one of the more memorable trademarks used by a Southern brewery during the late 19th century.
Robert Portner, a German immigrant, established his Alexandria brewing operation during the Civil War era. By the 1890s, the Tivoli Brewery had grown into one of the largest breweries in the South, distributing its lager, Hofbrau and other beers throughout Virginia, Washington, D.C., and much of the southeastern United States. The Alexandria brewery operated until statewide Prohibition forced it to close in 1916.
The bottle is hand-finished with an applied blob-style lip, originally designed for a reusable wire-bail closure with a porcelain or composition stopper.
The wording “This Bottle Not To Be Sold” reflects the returnable-bottle system of the period. Bottles remained the brewery’s property and were expected to be returned, washed and refilled—making this a genuine piece of Portner’s late-Victorian distribution system.
The pale blue-green aqua glass, strong embossing, applied top and scattered small bubbles give it excellent antique character. The embossing is unusually sharp throughout, including the difficult lower lettering.
Condition
Clean, bright example with exceptionally strong embossing. No chips, no cracks and no haze. There are numerous fine hairline scratches scattered across the surface, although it does NOT exhibit the heavier, concentrated “case wear” commonly seen on repeatedly reused beer bottles. Slight rust-colored transfer appears around the neck and applied lip from the original wire closure. The lip has a deflection mark with nearby rust transfer, shown closely in the photographs.
Date
Circa 1885–1895, with circa 1890 being my best single-year estimate. The “Robert Portner Brewing Co.” wording, applied blob closure and returnable-bottle warning fit the company’s major late-19th-century expansion period. A closely comparable Portner applied-blob Tivoli bottle is cataloged to 1899, supporting this general dating.
